oh for fuck god
don't make me never trust you with anything in my life again

unvote
vote: Lefafel

vote mostly because the role is *just* arcane enough that I believe it might actually be added in

'piece of piss' is a phrase that makes 0 sense in english lol

your defence is still very flimsy, but Lefa is now the quietest one of the bunch so time to pick on him instead - particularly since he also hasn't contributed anything to the situation at hand.

also

where in the fuck did you get this from? she just claimed to be a roleless townie (which is uncomfortably convenient for her in my opinion, but let that rest for now). check mafiascum before making an ass out of yourself

new players (such as myself in TM3) have a habit of messaging people who are not involved in the game, in order to bounce off ideas and whatnot on them. I know for a fact during TM3 there was at least one uninvolved person who knew the roles and situation of at least two people inside the game (though one of us was replaced fairly early on). whether it is ethical to agree to replace with that knowledge or not is a different story. I really don't want to base things off meta but since we've already broken the fourth wall long ago and there's no rule about meta, that would explain why mod didn't do anything even after lefa publicly admitted that his role is known by a different person, which is a double stupid situation from both sides, why would you ever do this, just go into goddamn PMs when discussing things.

this is really not convincing me of your innocence, though I admit others are seeming more suspicious than I initially felt

I'm too lazy to find that quote of abraker saying 'everything can be a puzzle piece' + that would be way too close to admitting he was actually right about something. neither of those were particularly significant in my read, I was just picking out everything that everyone who is still alive has said during d1.

which one? cause like I pointed out, you said two directly conflicting things about who would be killed

so why wouldn't you just vote TB in the first place, jumping on Mara for a moment instead?

discussed in my post as well as above and quoted below, your claims of who will and won't get lynched have been swaying back and forth to the extreme

please explain/provide your view on the following points/reads from my post

it may be beneficial to actually make Lefa claim as the very first person - if he is townie and it's highly likely mafia already knows his role (though I think Mara has some common decency and wouldn't necessarily share that knowledge), what's the harm in the rest of town finding out his role

bluh

it's been a year and a half, I guess we'll never find out what happens between definitely not legal vampire student and young male teacher who can afford armani pants yet sounds like a homeless crackhead

whoops I completely fucked up the link to most damning post

https://forums.tuuba.moe/viewtopic.php?pid=42130#p42130
for convenience

right, the following is my take on all of d1, written mostly for myself as a gathering of everyone's actions that heavily seems to implicate fittan. others may use this as a guide for going through the day, but I strongly implore people make up their own minds on the matter by reading through themselves before going through this (also, I'm not picking out information on myself because I know my alignment and role.)
skip to the end for my conclusions, vote and more.
Lefa was first to point fingers (at fittan), fittan was first to begin voting (at lefa)
fittan then did the suspicious move of throwing vote around that I called him out for
lefa voted fittan after this vote switch, being the second person to vote him at the time, which I found mildly suspicious
directly after I accused fittan, his only response was

this sounded suspicious to me because of the lack of any defence, and is where my first scumread came in. only after my read did fittan say something as defense, then provided his own read/possible deflection with suggesting that multtari is acting guilty
abraker's first post, mainly blaming me for contradiction. fittan tacks on saying "abraker could be smart scum but tupsu also looks guilty now" (sorry 4 paraphrase https://forums.tuuba.moe/viewtopic.php? … 16#p42016)
after some multtari discussion, fittan states he is "distancing from mafia" and defends soner (who is now confirmed to have been mafia). especially noteworthy quote

not 'probable townie', just 'someone who played like an idiot' - this sounds like a slip to me now that I have this additional information
I mention how heavily fittan has been pushing on me, fittan backpedals saying soner isn't off the hook but he doesn't think he is mafia
Lefa posts for the first time in a while, saying soner seems useless but probably not scum/harmless for now
Boat actually correctly points out fittan has been on the offensive for the whole day thus far - however so have I, so I really wouldn't take that as proof of anything
after me being blamed by abraker, Lefa posts again saying he's unconvinced and isn't moving his vote yet (which is sitting on fittan ever since page 2)
abraker posts his read/transcript thingy, which mostly claims I am scum, but does mention 'if tupsu is town, that implicates fittan as scum'
I ask him clarifying questions, he states "fittan showed restraint when saying that he wants to vote soner and realizes that even thought soner screwed up, that doesn't imply scum" - but if fittan is scum, no shit he doesn't want to actually vote soner (as we have confirmed he is now scum) as well as "He also admitted he can't really defend himself when you questioned his Granger vote", as well as "I don't see him trying to set anything up yet because he is not influencing the game enough, unlike you." - except standard mafia play is to distance self and try to not attract any attention to self, so I'm not sure what this is supposed to mean
as a response to my post, fittan for the first time explicitly claims pro-town, then rags on me for guessing mafia size

of course it would be more convenient for scum to have more scum with them. I just find this post very amusing now that he's an actual suspect. there is further discussion and back and forths between me/fittan/abraker here, where fittan tries to turn my suspicion back on me+granger, argument ensues
Lefa finally drops vote, convinced by abraker mentioning how fittan didn't try to defend themselves
fittan drops vote on me as he is going to work, stating he doesn't want to be useless as voting power - could also be read as him trying to detach in case I get hammered
Lefa speaks up, mentions how aggressive abraker has been against me, then states Multtari as suspicious as he has been quiet and lowkey while advocating for RVs to go through. this seems to be completely unrelated and I honestly can't tell if it implicates him as scum or not, but I'm leaning towards no as it would be more productive to try to jump on a vote train (particularly as fittan still had a number of votes on them, collecting some evidence against him prob wouldn't have been all too hard)
fittan responds to lefa saying his reasoning is pretty terrible and mentions he himself has done this, which may be nothing or may be sneakily trying to reduce the heat. at the same time I also do the exact same thing, mostly because at this point I'm 95% convinced fittan is town
I call out fittan asking to explain why he sees abraker as town, he responds he no longer knows as we seem to be opposite factions, but I don't seem full scum anymore (proven as false with abraker death). this is where Hika enters, fittan is extremely excited - just because we have decent players now, or because he's glad he has a decent scumbuddy now? (https://forums.tuuba.moe/viewtopic.php?pid=42097#p42097)
Lefafel begins fighting against/refuting abraker claiming his aggression mention is bullshit, then unvotes from multtari. this is suspicious to me as it may be a realisation that his attempted train is going nowhere, or it may be him still playing the accusation game and realising the pressure isn't leading to any information. neutral leaning
Hika first posts a proper read - "between abraker, tupsu and fittan, there is a scum", abraker is proven to be town with his death. "Granger, which is myself, was leaning scum to me because of inactivity but I can change that within the next few days." - this may be a slip claiming her as town but I highly doubt it from hika. she states abraker townslipped once (not sure what she means here) and mentions me going heavy on soner. https://forums.tuuba.moe/viewtopic.php?pid=42120#p42120
I respond stating I'm lost and hence pushing the soner vote hard, Hika responds saying it just makes me look like dumbtown
abraker accuses Lefa, fittan ignores this completely stating it has nothing to do with him. I would read this as scum distancing from one another, but it is evident they can't both be scum as they would be controlling half of the votes at this point if they were both scum. he states "If we just wait for someone to die at night, mafia is likely to kill someone who was outside accusations if they play smart.", but mafia tried to kill abraker, making this point suspicious as it directly seems to go 'I'm not mafia cause I wouldn't make this move'. with two experienced mafia players, playing 'dumb' would be the easiest way to make someone else look suspicious - too bad they voted abraker and not me, as I would've been completely powerless to responding this night. he also seems to have realised how close he looks to soner, stating "I was merely defending the dumbo because you can't blame people for being new/inexperienced/bad." clear distancing, presumably on the assumption that the soner lynch was dead and buried at this point since Mara had replaced. I started this post intending to just pull out everyone's actions and maybe get some idea of factions, but https://forums.tuuba.moe/viewtopic.php?pid=42130#p42130 is looking more and more damning to me.
he THEN votes Mara, clearly knowing at this point that said lynch will never come to pass and collecting easy 200$ from go by getting distancing points in. he makes no explanation of this besides "I want to lynch everyone". https://forums.tuuba.moe/viewtopic.php?pid=42131#p42131
Hika responds, telling fittan to calm down and that Soner still reads town to her, which is why she doesn't suspect Mara. this is disproven. Hika also points out fittan is not providing Mara an opportunity to explain - this is a slip from fittan, he's too caught up in collecting his 200$ and forgets that he's giving preferential treatment to Mara in showing how anti-Mara he is
fittan responds saying they want to see Mara prove themselves
Mara posts stating Soner was a retard, seems to me like he's trying to stop people from thinking why Soner would even think he's allowed to send pms with the whole drug mention (honestly I should've gone on mafiascum and looked up all the roles who change communication right away, that would've made this way easier and stopped boat from winning). fittan is the only person he doesn't say *anything* besides tldr on - I believe this is also a slip, forgetting that seeming too indifferent on someone also implicates them. it's obvious he was 100% sure he would not be dying, paid 0 notice to fittan's vote which further makes me believe it was agreed upon and could easily be revoked if shit was going down
Lefa calls out Mara for the shit post and votes boat, Hika also votes boat.
after receiving his 200$, fittan vote flips onto boat
abraker posts huge read on everyone, states hika as 40% fittan as 25% and lefa 66%. however, he also asserts mara is not scum, which is clearly false now and switches around the whole situation. if I'm feeling super ambitious I might tackle that entire post next as it's a good origin point to base percent reads and the change in information between days off of. however, the main reason he states fittan as so low is "sides with people appearing townie". this has been disproven - he heavily opposed me for most of game, and Mara was confirmed scum. mentions his uncanny towniness. abraker and I discuss this + the accidental meta that took place earlier.
Lefa responds to his scumread, which personally further reduces any chance that he's mafia to me.
fittan takes the last few hours of day to say "I agree with your scumread, here's more fishy things you missed about me", which further implicates him to me here, as it follows the previous pattern of "yes look at me I'm a silly regular dumb townie there is nothing weird about me". he now has flipped to "mafia will try to kill an active", which is a contradiction from the earlier and seems like a slip. https://forums.tuuba.moe/viewtopic.php?pid=42172#p42172
Lefa ends the day just by effectively saying 'well, I guess that's the lynch decided'.

tl;dr read the bolded pieces, they are the main reason why I am doing the following:

vote: fittan

I am sufficiently convinced in this read that I am pretty much ready to do a full roleclaim along with the breadcrumb proof I've previously given (but I'd definitely prefer to not be the first to do so). however, please remember that if I do happen to be wrong, it only takes two votes from town to enable mafia to win the game (my role is such that it can still lead to the win, however I really do not trust myself enough to make the right choice for this). read through everything, think about everything, ensure you are fully convinced in your read before pushing the vote.

if fittan is somehow not scum, my next suspicion is Lefa, but I feel that most of the idiosyncracies in his plays are explained by his inexperience in forum mafia. Hika has been playing exactly as she did during TM3 where she was a townie, and has mostly been very reasonable in my opinion, but I suppose she's not 100% non-suspicious. however, in my opinion, the evidence I collected implicates fittan to an extreme point.